Skip to main content
A large indoor swimming pool with lounge chairs and umbrellas.

Slice of Life: The Best Pizza in East Lansing MI

Everyone loves a good slice of pizza. Pizza is the default food in many situations. That's why it's so important to have at least one reliably delicious option nearby. Luckily, if you want a great slice of pizza, East Lansing, MI, is the place to be. Of course, the area has a ton of big chain places, but the real magic happens at the local mom-and-pop pizzerias.  

That's why we've curated a list of the best pizza in East Lansing, MI. Whether you love a good New York-style slice or you're more of a Chicago deep dish kind of person, we have you covered. Here are the top three best pizza places in East Lansing, MI, when you want an amazing slice.

A woman and a girl are eating pizza together.

Baba Ash Pizza & Grill 

In our search to find the best pizza in East Lansing, MI, Baba Ash Pizza & Grill quickly shot up to the top of the list. Almost every review on Google was a rave. We're not talking about just positive reviews. They were mostly glowing recommendations and ecstatic praise. Finding anyone with a bad word to say was a real challenge, and we were looking for them. 

So, what makes this the best pizza place in East Lansing, MI? According to reviews, the pizza and other food options are perfect. The crust is just the right thickness, the sauce is amazing, and the cheese and toppings are fresh and delicious. Plus, the staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating. They make people feel at home. They even reply to many of their reviews, and their personality really shines through. 

They also stand out for a few other reasons. Baba Ash has Halal options, which is vital if you have religious dietary restrictions. They have a wide range of food options, from calzones and pasta to salads, wings, and beyond. By all accounts, everything is amazing. Multiple people also raved about dessert specifically. They particularly loved the carrot cake and Oreo cheesecake. 

If you genuinely want to try the best pizza in East Lansing, MI, this is, hands down, the number one place to go. 

A person is cutting a pizza with a pizza cutter.

Bell's Greek Pizza 

This establishment calls itself a "Bare-bones parlor serving pies, sandwiches, wings & other casual fare till 4 AM nightly." They have a Greek-inspired menu with plenty of unique options, like gyro, spanakopita, and baklava, that people seem to love. They offer gluten-free pizza and even have live jazz music to enhance the atmosphere. 

The staff is friendly and helpful, the service is fast and courteous, and their prices are competitive. They have a lunch special for around $7 for two slices and a drink. They have some of the best pizza in East Lansing, MI. 

The photos in the reviews show pies covered in cheese with generous toppings that look like they're cooked to perfection. If you want an amazing pie or classic Greek delicacies, this is a great choice. 

Pizza House 

This place is described as a "Pizzeria with a roomy, laid-back dining room serving deep-dish pies & other Italian eats." If you're looking for Chicago-style pizza in East Lansing, MI, Pizza House has the best. If that's not your thing, though, they have a wide array of options to suit pretty much anyone. 

Their pizza options are plentiful. They offer traditional, thin-crust, super-thin-crust, Sicilian, Chicago deep-dish, Chicago stuffed, and gluten-free pizzas. They make calzones, wings, burgers, and other traditional options. Their salad menu is generous with plenty of options to choose from. 

They also have The Original Chipati®, a specialty of theirs, as well as other Chipati options. They offer several types of cheesy bread, which is clearly a sign of a place with amazing taste. Plus, they have a pretty substantial dessert menu and a section just for their "world-famous" shakes and malts. 

While they have more mixed reviews, with raves and one-star reviews side by side, they're worth a try for sure. Pizza House is one of the most diverse pizza places in East Lansing, MI. Their menu is perfect for when you have a group of people who can't agree on what to eat. 

A pizza with a slice missing, topped with tomato sauce, cheese, and meat.

A Little Slice of Heaven 

No matter what you want in a pizza, East Lansing, MI has a pie that is sure to satisfy. Residents of Castle Pointe apartments are surrounded by amazing pizza options. We didn't even mention the huge national chains scattered all over the area. You practically can't do anything in this area without stopping by one of the amazing pizza places East Lansing, MI has to offer.

If you're looking for a pet-friendly apartment in a prime location with all the amenities you could ask for, surrounded by amazing pizza, Castle Pointe is the place for you! We have 1-, 2-, and 3-bedroom options available. Contact us today to learn what we have to offer or schedule a tour to see for yourself!

Testimonials